

Love triangles have been a staple of pop culture since the dawn of time. As soon as we were old enough to read, we were forced to pledge allegiance to one relationship team and vehemently defend our ship until the end. Team Peeta vs. Team Gale. Team Edward vs. Team Jacob. We all knew exactly where we stood. The early aughts had us believing that in adulthood, we would be forced to choose between two loves, like all our favorite heroines had to.
While it’s been a while since the love triangle was the default trope for books, shows, and movies, summer 2025 is bringing one of our favorite triangles back to the forefront (thank god). The third and final season of The Summer I Turned Pretty dropped July 16, and while we’ll have to wait for the finale to find out who Belly chooses, Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah shippers are back with a vengeance.
Sure, you could rewatch the first two seasons or re-read the books to ensure you’ve made the correct pick, or hop on the bandwagon if you haven’t chosen a side yet. Or, like all good decisions, you could turn to the stars to see who you should really choose. Here’s what team you are, Conrad or Jeremiah, based on your zodiac sign.
Aries

Team Jeremiah
Aries are known for their competitive nature, and while Jeremiah may seem all smiles on the surface, he definitely has some tension brewing underneath. They can relate to his constant competition with his brother and his tendency to act on impulse rather than thinking through every decision. Their outgoing nature also leads them to root for Belly and Jeremiah since the two clearly seem to have more fun together.
Taurus

Team Conrad
Conrad has that signature Taurus stubbornness, and even if it’s frustrating as a viewer, Tauruses know the struggle all too well. They also identify with his practical, slightly possessive nature, where he’s willing to do anything for the people he loves, even when that means setting them free, as you scream at the TV for him to do anything else. You’re riding for Bonrad until the end, Taurus.
Gemini

Team Jeremiah
Jeremiah is the definition of a social butterfly, and as a super social, communicative sign, Geminis think he’s the better pick for Belly. As talkers, they could not put up with Conrad’s moody, silent brooding. Though knowing indecisive Geminis, they may change their team at any given moment.
Cancer

Team Conrad
Cancers are undoubtedly Team Conrad. As an emotional sign, they know precisely how Conrad feels when he puts up a protective shell and holds his true self close to the chest. They’re also a moody sign, so those Conrad mood swings don’t surprise them at all. They’re incredibly caring and sweet to those they love, so they can’t help but swoon at Belly and Conrad’s cutest moments.
Leo

Team Jeremiah
We all know Jeremiah loves the spotlight and knows how to charm a crowd, which is peak Leo behavior. Since Leos thrive on attention and affection, they love Jeremiah’s loyal, golden retriever nature. Plus, his ability to strike up a conversation and make anyone comfortable makes him the better choice for Belly, who has similar traits, according to Leos.
Virgo

Team Conrad
As the eldest brother, Conrad feels the responsibility that comes with his role in the family. Virgos recognize that hardworking spirit. They appreciate how Conrad commits to his goals and don’t get the Jere hype, thinking he’s not serious enough for Belly. Plus, Virgos value those who are thoughtful and dependable, which is Conrad through and through.
Libra

Team Conrad
Even though Conrad may be withdrawn at times, he is a romantic at heart. Libras love that he’s more emotional and deeper than Jeremiah. They want balance, harmony, and fairness, and Jeremiah’s spontaneous, unpredictable nature is too disruptive for them.
Scorpio

Team Conrad
While Team Jeremiah stans may criticize Conrad for not expressing his emotions very well, that’s exactly why Scorpios love him. They know that not sharing your feelings with everyone doesn’t mean they aren’t strong; it just means you prefer to feel truly safe with someone before pouring your heart out. As a misunderstood sign, they also relate to how Conrad isn’t always able to express his feelings to Belly, and they have their fingers crossed that the couple works out.
Sagittarius

Team Jeremiah
Sags are incredibly spontaneous and outgoing, just like Jeremiah. They love Jere’s endless energy and would get bored in a heartbeat with Conrad’s more predictable life. But like a true Sag, I wouldn’t be surprised if they never find out who she ends up with because they suddenly dropped off the face of the earth to go on a solo trip with no Wi-Fi, just because it sounded kind of fun.
Capricorn

Team Conrad
Conrad, like Capricorns, is ambitious and goal-oriented, but this often translates to being somewhat standoffish to outsiders. They know that Conrad’s stoic nature isn’t because he doesn’t care, but because he cares so much that he wants to make sure he can make a plan and execute it perfectly. While that might not always work out for him in the show, they know that Belly and Conrad are the superior match.
Aquarius

Team Jeremiah
As true individualists, Aquariuses are probably rooting for a secret third option for Belly to end up with (Cam Cameron, maybe?). Still, if they were forced to pick between Jeremiah and Conrad, they would go with Jere. They appreciate his outgoing and friendly nature, as well as his tendency to be very independent. So while they’re probably hoping Belly chooses herself and ditches both guys, they still lean slightly toward Team Jeremiah.
Pisces

Team Jeremiah
Pisces are dreamy and imaginative, and they like how Jeremiah kind of lives in his own world. Sure, it may come across as aloof at times, but as an imaginative sign themselves, they don’t mind if he’s not always grounded in reality. Conrad’s realism feels like pessimism to them and turns them off from Belly and Conrad as a couple.

Lauren Blue, Assistant Editor
As an Assistant Editor for The Everygirl, Lauren ideates and writes content for every facet of our readers’ lives. Her articles span the topics of must-read books, movies, home tours, travel itineraries—and everything in between. When she isn’t testing the latest TikTok trend, she can be found scouring Goodreads for new releases to feature on the site.
The post Is Your Zodiac Sign Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah? appeared first on The Everygirl.